Most Creative Directors were once young, aspiring art students with little to lose and stars in their eyes. They dreamed of one day owning an ultra-modern loft studio somewhere in Brooklyn or maybe, of becoming the next Basquiat.
They were capable of staying up all night editing the perfect noir sequence or spending hours getting the color of the sky just right, simply because they had nothing better to do. The art could come first, and because it did, the artist was happy and the art was pretty pure. Earning a living hadn't really entered the picture yet, nor had anything else that had to do with reality. You could still eat chips for dinner, mooch the university's art supplies and inside-out your laundry if you didn't have the change to wash it.
As I sit here typing and eating chip crumbs off my sweater, it occurs to me that it's a good idea to live in this pre-reality period for as long as you can. Stretch it out, but good, because once you pop the bubble, you're kind of screwed.
Fast-forward the art student a couple of years. All the lofts in the hipsy part of Brooklyn are taken, and Basquiat, well, he's been dead for ages, and it wasn't a very pretty story. (And although his art is still amazing, he's still dead. Not the best end to the dream.) By now inconvenient things like rent and respectability have entered the picture, bringing with them the need for cash, and not just a little bit of cash. It's time to grow up.
Enter advertising. Beckoning, seducing, lying.
Aspiring artists and writers become interns. Interns (if they are neither total idiots nor smart enough to get the hell out) become assistants, and assistants (if they are capable) become art directors or copywriters. And sometimes, art directors and copywriters (if they are still breathing) can become creative directors. And by the time you become Creative Director, if you've been paying attention, you figure out that the agency has simply by promoting you landed you back inside your bubble. (That's a long way to go for a ham sandwich, but there you are, the ham. And you're on top of the sandwich.)
At this point even I am wondering where I am going with this, so I'll get to the point.
Creative Directors have been through a lot to get where they are. They have made a lot of bad ads and have been largely told what to do by the creative directors who bossed them up the ladder. They are, essentially, artists who have been kept on a leash for ten or fifteen years, trying to build their portfolios whenever possible from mediocre ads that they had very little control over. Now they start to take it all back, and here's where it gets really interesting.
Creative Directors are usually agency principals. They have an interest in making the company profitable. But usually they would rather make art, and make it the way they made it back when they were in college. And here's the best part: they get to do it! And they're getting paid! And they have lackeys to get them coffee! So, they lobby, cajole and threaten the other principals (the grownups and the money guys) to choose boutique clients and projects that will be fun, interesting, challenging and look great in the portfolio, regardless of whether they are fiscally sound projects or not.
And oddly enough, the Creative Director, for whatever reason, usually gets his or her way. Maybe it's the tantrums, a sense of entitlement or a general spinelessness on the part of the other grownups, but whatever it is, here's what happens:
1) the Creative Director only wants to pitch business that will pad his or her portfolio
2) the Creative Director spends way too much time on these projects and goes over budget
3) the money guy begins to sweat
4) the Creative Director says "I don't care if we lose money. I just want to do it my way."
5) the client yells, the grownups make excuses, and people start to fight and quit
6) the Creative Director somehow gets his way
7) five or six people quit, the grownups make more excuses to the client and
8) everyone else is miserable.
And on and on. There's more on this, I swear, but I am out of chips.